Trojan TV tops list of Broadcast Challenge winners
The judges were super impressed by the entries in Challenge #3 Broadcast Story. Here’s those winners!
First Place: Shelby Fletcher, Rylie Estes, Logan Mitchell of Park Hill High School’s Trojan TV News
Second Place: Megan Duncan, Grace Bryson, McKenzie Whelan, Allison Meyer of Washington High School’s Blue Jay Journal TV
Third Place: Alicia Stout and Salome Yimer of Park Hill High School’s Trojan TV News
Honorable Mention #1: Kaden Meyer, Emma Duncan, Natalie Oesterly, Molly Tinkey of Washington High School’s Blue Jay Journal TV
Honorable Mention #2: Mary Garrett and Aidan Nolte of Park Hill South High School’s The South Side Scoop
JUDGE’S COMMENTS:
Judging this contest was an enjoyable process. I am impressed by the quality of the entries and the strength of the programs who entered. I really had a difficult time deciding between First and Second Place. Both of these story packages were top notch!
I want to point out that there were some issues that all broadcast students could all learn from.
- Great videography doesn’t matter if the reporter’s script is lacking. Writing matters! Yes, even in broadcast!
- I was a little underwhelmed by the amount of Sports entries. The theme was tradition. Sports can fit that well, but I do want to point out the Second Place winners from Washington looked beyond athletics and found something unique that fits that theme well.
- Do not be afraid to do stand ups. The First Place entry is just WOW. Shelby has a great voice and is a pro on camera! Well done! I am curious, did you really make that shot?
- WHITE BALANCE YOUR SHOTS! Nearly every entry had some issues with this. If you forget to white balance in the field, fix it in edit.
- Use a tripod.
- Include a sign out or tag.
- Natural sounds take us to a place. Audio is very important in Broadcast. I loved the First Place piece’s use of it, as well as Second Place! They both found great moments to insert natural sounds.
Overall, great job. I am excited for the future of broadcast when I see work like this put out by high school students! You are making sure the future of reporting and strong storytelling remains in good hands!
Rylie Estes • Feb 6, 2020 at 12:17 pm
Shelbys stand up is real! It only took us 17 times!